Due to the overwhelming surge in COVID-19 cases and the strain it has placed on health care capacity in the communities we serve, the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare has activated crisis standards of care statewide. We are open and available to see patients, but you may experience delays at our ERs, hospitals, and clinics. We appreciate your patience. Access more info on COVID testing, vaccination, visitor policy, hospitalization data, and FAQs.

toggle mobile menu Menu
toggle search menu

Site Navigation



Blog Post

St. Luke's Blogs

Why You Shouldn’t Spank Your Kids

May 12, 2014
Many people know that physical punishment, as a form of discipline, is actually effective. It stops the unwanted behavior temporarily. But it is simply not worth doing.

There are many unwanted effects to spanking as a form of discipline:

  • It’s usually done in anger and on impulse, so it is not well controlled.
  • People don’t want to hurt their children, so it’s inconsistent.
  • Hurting someone else deliberately is disrespectful, and can lower self-esteem.
  • It teaches children to be aggressive by modeling. It doesn’t make much sense to spank a child because the child hit someone else.
  • It isn’t educational, as other forms of discipline can be.
  • It replaces other effective forms of management.
  • It isn’t useful for older children.
  • Research has shown that children who have been spanked have an increased chance for alcoholism, depression, and spousal and child abuse.
For physicians: As part of the well visit in the early years, remember to ask your families what forms of discipline they use. If they mention spanking or hitting, then please share this information with them.

Based on a lecture by Barbara Howard, MD

About The Author

Noreen Womack, MD is a pediatrician at St. Luke's Clinic – Treasure Valley Pediatrics.

Related Specialty


Child wellness care and treatment for illness, injury, development issues, and psychological problems.

Related Clinic

St. Luke's Children's Treasure Valley Pediatrics: Eagle
450 W. State Street
Suite 100
Eagle, ID 83616
(208) 939-1035